My daughter-in-law pushed a stack of greasy plates into my hands and said, “Could you finish these? My mother prefers her wine chilled.”

being present without really being included.

After dessert, Brenda carried her wine into the living room.

David followed.

Rachel began stacking plates.

For one hopeful second, I thought she might wash them.

Instead, she walked straight toward me.

“Could you finish these up, Patricia?”

The stack landed in my hands.

“My mother prefers her wine chilled, and I need to entertain.”

Then she turned away.

I listened to her heels cross the hardwood.

The sink was already filled with cloudy water from pots I’d washed earlier. Grease floated beneath the